|
Accompanying Brazilian
President Lula to India next month would be a six-member national
football delegation of that country to India for betterment
of Indian soccer. Not unusual going by the fact that Indian
soccer is invaded by foreign players. The failure to create
its own pool of talent is forcing Indias football think-tank
to peep outside its geographical borders, often in search
of the players of Indian origin, who can salvage its pristine
pride. TWF correspondent Kushal Chakraborty traces the history
of foreign invasion in soccer.
Jose Barreto, Edmilson, Roberto Mendes Silva, Yusif
Yakubu, Ranti Martins this not a roll-call for an all-star
world soccer team. These are some of the foreign players who
are dominating the Indian football club rosters. In the Indian
soccer scenario induction of good foreigners is vital to the
success of a club. The craving for a foreign recruit has reached
such a pass that the Indian football officials are now seriously
thinking of giving Indian citizenship to some good foreign
footballers. Japan is lending the cue with the success of
Brazil-born Alex in its ranks.
The failure to create its own pool of talent is forcing the
country's football think-tank to peep outside its geographical
borders in search of the players of Indian origin who can
salvage its pristine pride. With the country's present world
ranking in soccer plummeting to 157, the mandarins of the
sports are taking recourse to a relatively new legislation
laid out by the sport's world governing body FIFA.
It is about the dual nationality of a player. In the Indian
context the law would broadly read like this -- A player playing
outside India but of Indian origin would be eligible to play
for the country if he has not represented the country where
is presently residing. Now with lot of the second or third
generation Indian expatriates making their presence felt in
different soccer leagues in Europe, the football administration
is seeing its deliverance in the new generation of NRIs.
Unlike cricket, which has remained largely insular to foreign
importation in terms of players, football in the country has
a long history of foreign dependence. Prior to the independence
several neighbouring countries like Pakistan, Burma (now Myanmar),
Sinhala (now Sri Lanka) contributed players to different Indian
clubs. This trend continued even after the independence with
players like Pagsali of Burma, Masud Fakri of Pakistan becoming
big names playing for reputed clubs in Kolkata.
The need to excel in a highly competitive format spurred
the Kolkata clubs to look outside the country for better talents.
In this effort to outscore each other, two clubs especially
East Bengal and Mohammedan Sporting played the pioneering
role. Mohun Bagan, being more conservative in principle, kept
itself away from this process of hiring foreign players initially.
Both East Bengal and Mohammedan Sporting were regularly reaching
outside the geographical boundaries to recruit players from
of different countries. Still, the clubs had some self-imposed
prohibitions. For example, East Bengal club did not recruit
Anglo-Indian players till 1942. East Bengal broke this embargo
with Fred Pagsali, an Anglo-Indian refugee from Myanmar. The
player went on to occupy a prominent spot in the pantheon
of the club's all-time stars with his exceptional skills as
a striker.
The year 1979 stands out as a watershed as refers the recruitment
of foreign players. Whereas Mohon Bagan failed to recruit
a Nepalese National Mohon Chhetri owing mainly to protests
from many of the club hardliners, East Bengal recruited Nigerian
striker David Williams. The player had come to Tamil Nadu
University to study and he became a big hit in the Calcutta
league after being drafted in by East Bengal. It was with
Williams' one outstanding season with East Bengal that the
clubs in Calcutta began to realise the importance of foreign
recruits. In 1980 after Williams had moved over to Mohammedan
Sporting, East Bengal brought in two Iranian footballers from
Aligarh Muslim University Majid Bakshar and Jamshed
Nasiri. These two added greater substance to the foreigner
theory with their superlative ball-playing skills and unparalleled
scoring abilities. Majid, an Iranian world cupper, eventually
became the greatest foreign footballer to have ever played
in the country.
In the later years, two other Iranians -- Khabazi and Sanjari
--joined Mohammedan Sporting. The two played with great merit
to further bolster the clubs' dependence on the foreigners.
With the clubs falling in for the foreigners, the 80s effectively
started the foreign invasion in football. Continuing with
the trend, Mohammedan Sporting recruited a player from Hyderabad
University in 1985. This started another landmark as the new
recruit responding to name of Chima Okorie went
on to become one of the finest scorers in Indian football
playing for a host of clubs in a career spanning more than
a decade.
This was time Mohun Bagan was beginning to realise the inefficacy
of its stubbornness in not going for imports. It broke the
convention finally in 1992 and did so in style bringing in
Chima as its first foreign recruit. By this time East Bengal
had made it their habit bringing hordes of foreigners every
season. East Bengal had introduced another future star in
1986 picking up Emeka Ezuego from Aligarh Muslim University.
After a brief stint in Kolkata and Dhaka, Emeka went back
to his native country Nigeria and represented his national
side in the 1998 World Cup. The stream of foreign invasion
continued with the likes of Charles Appu, Chibuzor, Johny,
Santos who was perhaps the first Bazilian player to
play in the country joining East Bengal.
The cue was taken over by even smaller clubs, like George
Telegraph, Port Trust, picking up foreigners in their roster.
In the later years East Bengal further embellished its illustrious
record of foreign recruitment reaching out to England from
where they brought in the trio of Peter Maguire, Prindevelly,
and Edmonds early in the 90s. Mohun Bagan picked up late but
in the last 15 years it has caught up with the race along
with other clubs in the country to make it a pan-Indian phenomenon.
Going by the performances of foreign players in Indian soccer,
it can be said without any doubt that Africa-born players
are more successful than the imports from the other continents.
The last decade has seen the biggest proliferation in this
phenomenon with the clubs in Goa, Kerala, Mumbai, and Punjab
garnishing their squads with plucking from virtually all across
the world. The past has seen the likes of Chima, Kenyan Sammy
Omello, Ghanaians Sule Musha and Jackson Agygpong, Nigerians
Emanuel Opoku, Bernard Oparanzie, Christopher among others.
Now with Brazilians turning their attention to India, the
clubs rosters have a healthy presence from the land of Samba.
Led by Jose Barreto, who can easily be ranked among one of
the foreigners to have ever played in the country, there are
many other Brazilians who are tugging the fortune of the clubs
in the country. The other successful Brazilian in the Indian
conditions was Cristiano Junior, who met an untimely end on
field in the 2004 Federation Cup final at Bangalore.
The import scene has improved somewhat with the change in
the pattern of recruiting foreign players. Earlier most foreigners
came either as students or as a tourist, but now the foreign
players are recruited through agents. Still, the level of
excellence has not improved much as the quality players, especially
from Europe or Latin America, are not willing to play in the
country.
The final round up on the issue would come best from the
former players. According to Aloke Mukherjee, former international
and Indian coach, the foreign players are now integral part
of Indian soccer. They certainly help in improving the standards
by showing the Indian players the grade to perform, he says.
Surajit Sengupta, former Indian captain, says that most of
the foreigners who come to play in the country are often of
mediocre standards. The only ones who are very exceptional
compared to the Indian players can only make their mark. This
is paradoxical situation where the talented foreigners often
prefer good professional leagues in Europe and Asia (like
in Japan and Korea), leaving only the ones without any option
search the route to India, he says.
Tarun De, another international footballer, says the Indian
clubs hardly make a quality check on the foreigners. To recruit
a foreign player club officials need to be more professional
in their approach.
|